[wp-hackers] Funky Four-O-Four

[Brian Layman]

I'd normally ask this through the support forum, but this seems a little
advanced for many of the readers there.  

I think you all would be the ones to answer this, even if I posted it there.
Besides, perhaps there is something /deep/ in the WP code that is
specifically blocking this action... Though I don't see how it would even
get into WP's realm of influence (this should be all Apache), /something/ is
happening.  I've provided screen shots as proof of my statements.

My problem centers around a file in my themes directory:
WPPATH/wp-content/themes/WP-Binary-Blue-v110/single_comments.php
I've gotten some 249 404s for that file this month.  I have an additional 14
for single_content.php which is called by the MORE function... I've removed
most of my MORE references.  That's why that count is so low...

The file clearly exists: 
http://www.thecodecave.com/images/404/dirstruct.PNG

but when I connect to it from the browser, I get a 404...
http://www.thecodecave.com/wp-content/themes/WP-Binary-Blue-v110/single_comm
ents.php
http://www.thecodecave.com/images/404/browser.PNG

I have one .htaccess file in that entire directory branch.  It is located in
my root WP directory and currently contains:

IndexIgnore .htaccess */.??* *~ *# */HEADER* */README* */_vti*

# Showing off
Redirect /csrf.txt http://www.thecodecave.com/?p=105

# A couple redirects I want to keep from when I've tried different permalink
formats
Redirect
/2006/05/26/copy-as-text-link-and-copy-as-image-link-blogging-tools/
http://www.thecodecave.com/?p=152
Redirect /Article68 http://www.thecodecave.com/article68
Redirect /2006/05/28/lg-vx5200-lg-vx6000-lg-vx7000-lg-vx8100-stuff/
http://www.thecodecave.com/article113

# BEGIN WordPress
<IfModule mod_rewrite.c>
RewriteEngine On
RewriteBase /
RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} !-f
RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} !-d
RewriteRule . /index.php [L]
</IfModule>
# END WordPress


The behavior is identical, whether .htaccess contains the above, or if I
blank it out and have nothing in .htaccess.

The rights on the directory structure and the file itself are 755:
http://www.thecodecave.com/images/404/dirrights.PNG
http://www.thecodecave.com/images/404/filerights.PNG

I have all of my capitalization correct...

WHAT AM I MISSING?????

Please tell me it is something simple so I can smack myself on the head and
put this to rest!